A1 rebutted by A2 on A1 A2 mitigated by A3 on A1 A1 "You will get wet!" { supported by F1 "It is raining " warranted by DK1 "If it is raining you will get wet " } A2 "I am fine " round 1 { supported by F2 "I have a shelter " round 1 { supported by F3 "I am inside a room " round 1 } warranted by DK2 "One will get wet only if it is raining and one does not have a shelter " round 1 replacing DK1 with !DK1 & (F1 & !F2 -> A1) } A3 "You still will get wet " round 2 { supported by F4 "because the roof is leaky " round 2 warranted by DK3 "Leaky roof removes the shelter " round 2 replacing F2 with !F2 }